01 - November 2022 - 8th/22 games - 7 votes

02 - December 2022 - 12th/21 games - 6 votes

03
January 2023 - 5th/16 games - 10 votes
February - 12th/20 games - 7 votes
April - 14th/19 games - 3 votes
February 2025 - 18th/24 games - 5 votes

04 - April 2023 Fool's Choice - 10th/23 games - 6 votes

05 - May 2023 - 16th/18 games - 3 votes

06 - June 2023 - 6th/14 games - 6 votes

07
July 2023 - 3rd/17 games - 12 votes
August - 8th/17 games - 7 votes

08
September 2023 - 8th/18 games - 6 votes
October - N/A - N/A (Not included in the polls because it wasn't a horror game.)
November - 12th/15 games - 5 votes
May 2024 - 15th/18 games - 4 votes

09 - February 2024 - 8th/14 games- 8 votes

10 - June 2024 - 17th/18 games - 2 votes

11 - July 2024 - 5th/15 games - 7 votes

12
August 2024 - 12th/19 games - 5 votes
September - 8th place/14 games - 7 votes

13 - October 2024 - 4th/18 games - 9 votes

14 - November 2024 - 2nd/17 games - 10 votes

15 - December 2024 - 8th/17 games - 7 votes

16 - January 2025 - 9th/19 games - 6 votes

17 - February 2025 10th Anniversary - 14th/21 games - 5 votes

18 - March 2025 - 21st/21 games - 1 vote

19 - April 2025 - 12th/22 games - 7 votes

20 - April 2025 Fool's Choice - 11th/16 games - 3 votes

21 - May 2025 - 15th/23 games - 5 votes

22
June 2025 - 7th/20 games - 7 votes
July - 7th/21 games - 8 votes
August - 12th/23 games - 6 votes
September - 14th/21 games - 6 votes

23 - Itchmas in July 2025 - 11th/16 games - 5 votes

24 - October 2025 - 4th/16 games - 7 votes